Abstract

A robotic-scribe learns to forget between making marks and making meaning.


Full Text / Read More

I Don't Know What I Think Until I See What I Write


A robotic-scribe is programmed to 'learn' from its own mark-making, not unlike a child learns to draw by first "following the line" and then later attributing meanings and symbols to the outcomes of their drawings (1). The system autonomously adjusts its physical movements and evaluates (previously unforeseen) results, constantly transforming and destroying in a process of experimental exploration. Only when the system determines that a drawing has reached sufficient qualities (currently these include spatial entropy, line fluidity, complexity, or energy) it will attempt to attribute one or more meanings to it, memorising the gesture for future use in its own constantly transforming nonhuman writing system.

I Don't Know What I Think...
I Don't Know What I Think..., [Robotic-scribe], 2025, Steel, PLA plastic, micro-controllers, electric motors, etched acrylic, horse-hair brush, Various, Karen ann Donnachie & Andy Simionato.

The robotic-scribe and its writing system.

This automated-art-system emerged from experiments with non-Euclidean drawings and typefaces. We built a 2-arm drawing-machine and designed software to operate it as a polar-coordinate mark-making system capable of executing resolution-independent gestural movements which use no segmentation of paths. The 2-arm machine and custom-coded software permits the system to leverage the rotational movements of the motors in order to closely mimic calligraphy or some styles of hand-writing (2).

I Don't Know What I Think...
I Don't Know What I Think... , [overhead machine view], 2025.

Rather than attempting to use existing methodologies for CNC line-drawing, which typically involves calculating the inverse kinematics of a desired path and then breaking these paths into a chain of smaller movements, we designed a system which is resolution independent by privileging the affordances of what we consider the machine's "native" elliptical geometries. The result is a novel drawing system capable of solving for all available paths for any given pair of destination points within a specified manifold space using only the (non-segmented) elliptical paths made possible by the motors. Highly "looping" paths can be combined with more direct (but always non-linear) "shortest distance" paths to generate drawings. What the system may lose in accuracy (when compared to traditional CNC methods) it gains in efficiency, speed and fluidity of execution.

Glyph generation from prototype of IDKWIT system
Glyph generation from prototype of IDKWIT system, [IDKWIT archive tool], 2025, digital file, 1024px, Karen ann Donnachie & Andy Simionato.

How the system evaluates its outcomes.

Over the course of the first few drawing sessions, the automated-art-system generated several hundred drawings. It became evident we risked becoming overwhelmed with drawings, so we introduced a secondary "curatorial algorithm" which aims to select drawings with sufficient salience, while discarding the remainder. The system's evaluation of the drawings involves assessing its spatial entropy/harmony, flow/complexity, and efficiency/energy (or power). These criteria, which remain in flux, have been determined through the study of calligraphic traditions such as Chinese shūfǎ (書法), and Japanese shodō (書道). (3)

Morphological evolution graph
Morphological evolution graph, [Digital artwork (software)], 2025, digital file, 1024px, Karen ann Donnachie & Andy Simionato.

Autopoiesis and mark/meaning making.

Once a drawing is evaluated for inclusion in the system's archive it is parsed through a third and final function which attempts to associate the drawing to one or more meanings or concepts. This process is also in constant flux, currently using a mix of Computer Vision functions and real-world environmental measurements to attribute meaning to the drawing and link it to other drawings. This database of (potential) morphemes was then reintegrated to the automated-art-system.

I Dont Know What I Think...
I Dont Know What I Think..., [Drawing from first prototype], 2025, Ink, Paper, 150 x 210 mm, Karen ann Donnachie & Andy Simionato.
I Dont Know What I Think...
I Dont Know What I Think..., [Drawing from first prototype], 2025, Ink, Paper, 150 x 210 mm, Karen ann Donnachie & Andy Simionato.

It could be argued that the changes in behaviour we are currently observing in the robotic-scribe represents the results of intermeshing external (environmental) influences with the system's internal (programmed) impulse to draw. Will this behaviour –that appears to happen somewhere between making marks and making meaning– lead to a nonhuman writing system?

I don't know what I think, until I see what I write.

I Don't Know What I Think...
I Don't Know What I Think..., [Process image showing robotic-scribe and some outcomes], 2025, Various, Various, Karen ann Donnachie & Andy Simionato.


Notes

1 Ellen Dissanayake, 2016. "Mark-Making as a Human Behavior" in Darwin's Bridge: Uniting the Humanities and Sciences, [Joseph Carroll (ed.) et al.], Oxford University Press, 103—130. https://academic.oup.com/book/9959/chapter/157310748

2 This is especially evident when we consider the common advice given to apprentice sign-writers and letterers is to use the arms in a rotational movement, instead of manipulating the brush or pen with only their hands and fingers.

3 Evolving this "curatorial rubric" is fundamental to the evolution of the robot scribe's writing system; for this reason we link the values of each of these criteria to every saved drawing in the structured database which the system is building.

4 Autopoiesis is a concept describing (primarily living) systems that create and maintain themselves by continuously producing their own components through a circular network of processes. Coined by biologists Humberto Maturana and Francisco Varela, it signifies "self-creation" and is characterized by self-production and self-distinction, where the network of components generates the system itself. Because of its common use in biology, we wish to avoid the risk of anthropomorphism by underlining our use of the term here is intended only to describe the outcomes of the cybernetic feedback loops within the automated-art-system in question.
 


Artworks by this System

) The Center for Computational Unknowing
Legal notice

At the CCU we practice many experimental art techniques of appropriation, including computational collage where existing publications (including books and magazines) and other found printed matter, are 'cut-up' and recombined into new works. The use of these found materials means that parts of the original publications may be included in the final artworks and/or process documentation. In such cases, we acknowledge the use of the original somewhere in the didactic description or directly within the work itself. However, any inclusion of the found publication, or part thereof, in the final artwork should not imply any endoresment of the CCU by the original publication's authors or publishers. All enquiries should be directed to our offices.


 
Acknowledgements

All artworks and texts, unless otherwise stated, are published courtesy the artists, 'Donnachie, Simionato & Sons' (2024). Visual and textual materials on this site may only be reproduced for scholarly purposes and with citations. Please forward all enquiries to contact@unknowing.cc

Many of the automated-art-systems in the CCU utilise open-source software and hardware which would not exist without the contribution of their respective communities. Special thanks to Processing (Java and Javascript); arduino (C++) and Raspberry Pi systems; Python; Inkscape.



Atomic Activity Books

Official publishing partners to the CCU. At www.AtomicActivity.com you can find limited editions from the Library of Nonhuman Books, as well as art multiples from many of the CCU's other automated-art-systems. Explore the entire catalogue of books and objects at the Atomic Activity website, or from selected bookstores.



studiok+a

Web design and development. The CCU platform is published through a custom-coded archival system which uses PHP, mySQL, Javascript, HTML and CSS. The CCU is grateful for any reports of errors or oversights, and will endeavour to implement corrections and improvements as soon as possible.